• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Kimberly Pizza: A Time-Honored Family Favorite in New Haven

At Kimberly Pizza, tradition meets flavor in a warm, family-owned atmosphere. Located at 34 Kimberly Ave in New Haven, Connecticut, this iconic pizzeria has been delighting customers for years. A cherished favorite for many, including longtime patrons like Mirnelis M., who fondly recalls enjoying their famous slices since childhood. The cash-only establishment prides itself on serving authentic, handcrafted pizzas with recipes that have remained intact over time, ensuring a true taste of home. With highlights like their mushroom and bacon combination and hearty steak & cheese, Kimberly Pizza embodies comfort food, consistently bringing families together around the table.

Kimberly Pizza at a glance

  • Address 34 Kimberly Ave New Haven, CT 06519 United States
  • Phone (203) 498-2581
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Greek restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Kimberly Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Kristy Ramos
5

Have been my family favorite pizza for ever, they sausage is the best. I dont live in Ct but I Always stop here on vacation.

L Weav
5

My girlfriend and i love this pizza! We ate here last night foe the first time! You can tell this is authentic greek pizza. This plce Haas been around since i was a kid, imm not sure why i ever stopped eating here. However the pizza was delicious, we will be back!!!

Albert “No Onions” Ruggiero
4

Takes you right back to the 80s from the way the joint looks, to the taste of the pizza, even how you pay harkens back to the 80s: cash only. Lol. It really just took me back. Tastes like pizza did when we were kids. Check them out if you want something both different AND nostalgic.

Israel C.B
5

I grew up coming here 20 years later still traveling to get me some Kimberly pizza. Amazing owner

Sara Mota
5

This is the taste of my childhood and definitely still my favorite so far! Kimberly's pizza has such a unique taste that i havent been able to find anywhere else. Ive lived in Jersey and now in Miami and nothing else comes close. Next time I come visit I'll eat a slice of home. Keep up the good work and hopefully the quality stays the same!

Raquel Baez
5

I treat my classroom staff for birthdays, etc. They love Kimberly Pizza. Always ready on time. If you go, it's only cash, it'sworth it. I've been eating their pizza for more than 25 years.

Sof A Loaf
5

Just how I remember it from when I was a kid!!! I haven’t been here in over 10 years and it brought back so many memories. The pizza was delicious, fresh and crispy. Ughh they made my day today!!

Nidia Lopez
5

Just a classic Gem pizza Isn’t nostalgic it brings back memories when you were a kid. Thin buttery crust, flavor of sauce, and we’re not gonna forget the toppings. I love the sausage still original to this day, so yes, please try. This pizza is amazing cause it’s one of my favorites. I hope they never changed the recipe.

Location

  • Kimberly Pizza
    Kimberly Pizza
    34 Kimberly Ave New Haven, CT 06519 United States Hotline: (203) 498-2581

Welcome to the delectable world of Kimberly Pizza, a cherished gem nestled in New Haven, Connecticut. This beloved family-owned establishment has earned its reputation as a must-visit destination for pizza lovers, with a history that spans generations.

Located at 34 Kimberly Ave, New Haven, CT 06519, Kimberly Pizza prides itself on delivering authentic, mouthwatering pizza that resonates with the spirit of home cooking. The restaurant's cozy ambiance and warm hospitality make it the perfect spot for gatherings with loved ones.

  • Timeless Recipes: Customers rave about the enduring charm of Kimberly Pizza, celebrating its tried-and-true recipes that have remained intact over the years. Mirnelis M., a loyal patron since childhood, describes the place as a "slice of home," highlighting how it evokes nostalgia and comfort with every bite.
  • Cash Only, Great Value: Luz M. points out the simplicity of Kimberly Pizza's cash-only policy, which adds to its unpretentious allure. The focus is squarely on delivering an incredible dining experience, rich in flavor and value.
  • Signature Offerings: In addition to classic pizza, Kimberly Pizza has drawn fans with its other savory offerings. Will S. mentions the delight of enjoying their half-mushroom, half-bacon pizza or indulging in a delicious steak and cheese. It's a menu that appeals to a variety of tastes, making it a versatile dining choice for families and friends.

Each bite from Kimberly Pizza is a celebration of flavors. Whether you're a returning customer or a first-time visitor, the magic of their pizza is undeniable. The crust is perfectly baked, the sauce is rich and tangy, and the toppings are generously piled high, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality.

In conclusion, Kimberly Pizza is not just a restaurant—it's an experience. With its reputation for excellence, deep-rooted traditions, and a menu brimming with favorites, it's no wonder that this pizza hub continues to capture the hearts of so many. Don't miss out on your chance to enjoy a slice of Kimberly Pizza; it truly promises to be a journey of flavors and cherished memories.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Cash only